Council vote

From Crusader Kings II Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search

A council vote is triggered for law changes or important interactions, depending on council laws.

Stances[edit]

Each council member must select a stance, a general attitude on how the realm should be governed. This stance usually determines how the AI votes on laws, and completely determines how all council members vote on interactions.

  • Highly supportive voters may be Loyalist 
  • Most voters will select one of three “neutral” stances: Pragmatist , Glory Hound , or Zealot 
  • Highly unsupportive voters may be Malcontent 

AI characters select their stance based on their traits, size/power, and relations with their liege.

Stance In-game description +Modifiers -Modifiers
Loyalist large.png Loyalist A Loyalist councilor will generally be a faithful servant to the ruler. They will support their liege in all actions except those that will directly decrease their own power.
  • +10 Content 
  • +5 Trusting 
  • +10 Dynasty close relative.png Close relative
  • +5 Dynasty distant relative.png Distant dynast
  • +10 Friend
  • +5 Lover
  • +10 when opinion ≥ 95
  • +0.4 × opinion
Negative opinion makes this impossible, even for players
Pragmatist large.png Pragmatist A Pragmatist councilor will always aim for the path of least resistance when it comes to strengthening the realm and gaining power for themselves. They are inclined to support wars for reclaiming of de-jure land or provinces with the ruler's culture. They might also support wars against weak opponents. This councilor will oppose the creation of other strong vassals in the realm and will support the revoking of titles from already powerful vassals.
  • 30 base
  • +10 Cynical 
  • +10 Craven 
  • +10 Just 
  • +10 Paranoid 
  • (20a + 100s)
  • -10 Content 
  • -10 Arbitrary 
  • -10 Slothful 
  • -10 Greedy 
  • -50 Zealous 
Glory Hound large.png Glory Hound A Glory Hound councilor will always push for the realm to make prestigious advances for glory. They will oppose attacking weak neighbours, but against more powerful opponents they will not care much for the reason of the war as long as it will strengthen the realm. This councilor also prefers a strong and centralized realm.
  • 30 base
  • +10 Brave 
  • +10 Honest 
  • +10 Proud 
  • (15a + 100p)
  • -50 Craven 
  • -10 Shy 
  • -10 Humble 
  • -10 Content 
Zealot large.png Zealot A Zealot councilor will strive towards bringing religion to the forefront of the realm's political agenda. If religious war targets are available this councilor might oppose wars against other targets. The councilor will also be more inclined to accept hostile action against heathen and heretic characters.
  • 20 base
  • +25 Zealous 
  • +10 Humble 
  • +20 Theocracy
  • +20 Liege could be crusading but isn't
  • +5 Has at least 5 piety
  • +5 Crusader , Mujahid , or Valhalla bound.png
  • (15a + 45s + 45p)
  • -10 Liege has 200 piety
  • -10 Content 
  • -50 Cynical 
Malcontent large.png Malcontent A Malcontent councilor is unhappy with the current state of affairs in the realm. They are a troublesome force on the council and will always oppose the will of the ruler unless they directly stand to gain power.
  • 15 base
  • +5 Ambitious 
  • +10 Envious 
  • +5 additional from envious if neither ambitious nor content
  • +20 Rival
  • -1.6 × negative opinion
  • (25a + 50s + 50p)
  • -15 Content 
  • -5 Trusting 
  • -0.7 × positive opinion

Influence of size and power[edit]

The cryptic parts above are based on realm size and power:

  • a is the vassal's absolute size, divided by 50, then squared
  • s is the vassal's size, compared to the liege
  • p is the vassal's power, compared to the liege

It looks like the overall effect of these terms is:

  • Vassals of any significance tend not to be loyalists
  • Vassals with more size than power tend to be pragmatists
  • Vassals with more power than size tend to be glory hounds
  • Huge vassals (i.e. ruling multiple kingdoms) tend to be malcontent, due to the squaring in a

Stance selection[edit]

AI characters select the stance with the highest score. Note that appointing someone may change their scores, because the very act of appointing them can shift opinion and the size of vassal levies!

Not listed above are that horses are always loyalists, and that vassal khans under the greatest_of_khans are usually loyalists. Generally, the characters most likely to be loyalists are those with high opinion and the Content  trait.

Law votes[edit]

Law votes take place over several months. This allows players to choose a vote that does not match their general stance, and gives everyone time to grab favors.

Council laws[edit]

Loyalists will vote with the liege. Everyone else will vote to empower the council.

Realm laws[edit]

For voters with the three neutral stances:

  • Increasing Centralization: most voters will support at 20 opinion, and otherwise be undecided
  • Decreasing Centralization: most voters will support
  • Increasing Status of women: women support and men oppose
  • Increasing Revocation: in general, they will vote "no" if opinion is below 60 and remain undecided even above that. However:
    • A Pragmatist  will vote yes for the first level at opinion 20, since they appreciate the need for distribution of power within the realm.
    • A Zealot  will vote yes for the second level at opinion 20, since they want infidels to have their titles revoked.
  • Increasing Tribal Organization: reformed religion or not tribal
  • Decreasing Tribal Organization: unreformed religion or tribal
  • Increasing Viceroyalties: most voters are opposed
  • Increasing Regulation of inheritance: most voters are opposed
  • Increasing Administration type: most voters are opposed
  • Changing Investiture: all voters are undecided (even loyalists)

Vassal obligations[edit]

  • Feudal/iqta and tribal rulers prefer to pay taxes
  • Republic rulers prefer to provide levies
  • Theocratic rulers prefer balanced obligations

Courtiers vote as if they had the same government type as their liege, since they hope to someday be granted a county. Voters are undecided on obligations that do not affect their government group.

Interaction votes[edit]

Votes on interactions, such as declarations of war, are immediate and determined by fixed rules called patterns. This allows the liege to proceed without waiting, reduces uncertainty, and prevents a proliferation of popups for vassals.

Voting patterns are evaluated in order until one of them matches a yes or no: selfish pattern Dynasty player.png, family pattern Dynasty close relative.png, stance pattern Loyalist.pngPragmatist.pngGlory Hound.pngZealot.pngMalcontent.png, and opinion pattern. Within each pattern, "for" reasons are usually more important than "against" reasons. If none of these patterns suggests a "for" or "against" vote, they will be swayed by the diplomacy skill of voters who care.

The liege can override "no" votes on interactions. However, acting against the will of the council is considered an act of tyranny, and also makes the council discontent. During a regency, it is impossible to overrule the council and the ruler does not even get a vote.

Declare war[edit]

Pragmatist  and Glory Hound  councilors have nearly opposite goals. Pragmatists generally support attacking weak enemies, while glory hounds generally support attacking strong enemies. Allies are included in their strength calculations. When each side in the war would have similar strength, they consider other factors.

A Zealot  will almost always support attacking targets of other religions. They will also support wars within the religion if there is a strong religious motivation for the war and no ongoing crusade.

Pattern Vote Tooltip Notes
Dynasty player.png Me for  ? When the council member initiated the vote?
Dynasty player.png Selfish for I would gain a title!
Dynasty player.png Selfish against I would lose a title!  ???
Dynasty close relative.png Family for My family member would gain a title! "Gainer" (e.g. claimant?) is close relative
Dynasty close relative.png Family against This war is against one of my family members Defender is close relative
Dynasty close relative.png Family against My family member would lose a title! Contested title is held by a close relative
Loyalist.png Loyalist for This voter is a Loyalist and will vote like the liege Liege initiated the vote
Loyalist.png Loyalist against - Liege did not initiate the vote (someone is trying to use a favor to force the liege to press their claim)
Pragmatist.png Pragmatist against We're already busy fighting another war Primary participant
Pragmatist.png Pragmatist for The opponent is much weaker than us Attacker power ≥ 1.3
The CB is NOT claim for other (worried that such a war would make another vassal too powerful?)
Pragmatist.png Pragmatist for The targeted land is part of our De Jure territory or it is of our Culture Group Attacker power ≥ 0.8
Any county (controlled by the defender within the contested title) is of our culture group or a de jure part of any of the attacker's titles
Pragmatist.png Pragmatist against The opponent is too strong for us to take on Attacker power < 1.0
Glory Hound.png Glory Hound for The opponent is stronger than us, this war will be glorious! Defender power ≥ 0.9
Glory Hound.png Glory Hound for This is my preferred war target!  ?
Glory Hound.png Glory Hound for Winning this war will grow the realm! Attacker power < 3.0
When pressing the claim of a courtier who would need land to remain your vassal, a Glory Hound expects you to give the courtier land before declaring war. As if you'd forget.
Glory Hound.png Glory Hound against There is no glory in this war, the enemy is too weak Defender power < 0.3
Zealot.png Zealot against The target is not an antipope of another religion Depose Antipope CB, councilor has a different religion(?)
Zealot.png Zealot against There is an ongoing Crusade that I want us to focus on When declaring war on an enemy of our own religion, this overrides all "for" reasons
Zealot.png Zealot for The war would depose a wicked pope Defender is pope with the Bad priest christian.png Wicked Priest trait.
Gainer is our antipope and does not have the trait.
Zealot.png Zealot for The war is against a religious enemy! The defender (or the holder of the contested title) does not share our religion
Note: Catholic and Orthodox are considered "religious enemies" in this clause, even though they are not normally hostile.
Zealot.png Zealot for The war is against an Excommunicated character [of our religion]
Zealot.png Zealot for The war [would depose] an Antipope Depose Antipope CB, councilor has the same religion(?)
Zealot.png Zealot against There is an ongoing Crusade that I want us to focus on When declaring war on an enemy of a different religion, this is just a fallback (?)
Malcontent.png Malcontent against This voter is Malcontent and will oppose the liege
Pragmatist.png
Glory Hound.png
Zealot.png
Preferred war target against There are other wars that are more important for me right now.

Each voter with a “neutral” stance will try to select a preferred war target:

  • Pragmatist: not a close relative, ___ power ___
  • Glory Hound: not a close relative, ___ power between ___ and ___
  • Zealot: not a close relative, not the same religion, ___ power ___

When hovering a councilor's portrait, their tooltip will indicate whether they have a preferred war target and who it is.

Enforce Realm Peace[edit]

Pattern Vote Tooltip Notes
Dynasty player.png Me for  ? When the council member initiated the vote?
Dynasty player.png Selfish for I am losing a war, this would save my hide! Defender is voter or voter's ally.
Attacker is more powerful or war score is not clearly in my favor
🐞 Defenders are confused and think they're losing when they're actually winning
Dynasty player.png Selfish for My ally is losing a war, this would help them
Dynasty player.png Selfish against I am winning a war
Dynasty player.png Selfish against My ally is winning a war
Loyalist.png Loyalist for This voter is a Loyalist and will vote like the liege Liege initiated the vote
Malcontent.png Malcontent against This voter is Malcontent and will oppose the liege

Grant Landed Title[edit]

Only applies to "Grant landed title". You can always use "Grant viceroyalty", "Create new vassal", or allow your chancellor to distribute excess titles.
Pattern Vote Tooltip Notes
Dynasty player.png Selfish for I would gain a title!
Dynasty player.png Selfish for You are vastly over your Demesne Limit and are handing out a Barony or a County Liege exceeds demesne limit by 4
Liege is not nomadic
Title rank is barony or county
Dynasty player.png Selfish against I am unlanded, I should get the title! Voter is landless, recipient is already landed.
Liege does not exceed demesne limit by 2.
Liege is not nomadic
Note: applies even to duchy grants!
Dynasty player.png Selfish against The title is part of my De Jure territory, it should be mine! Direct de jure vassal title (?)
Dynasty player.png Selfish against I desire this title De jure liege title or above (?)
Dynasty close relative.png Family for My family member would gain a title! Close relative and NOT a rival
Loyalist.png Loyalist for This voter is a Loyalist and will vote like the liege
Pragmatist.png Pragmatist against The targeted characters demesne is 4 or larger
Pragmatist.png Pragmatist against I do not want you to grant land to your Dynasty! Unless voter is also of your dynasty
Zealot.png Zealot for Same religion, 20 opinion
Zealot.png Zealot against Different religion, below 25 opinion
Zealot.png Zealot against Same religion, decadent 
Zealot.png Zealot against Same religion, excommunicated 
Malcontent.png Malcontent against This voter is Malcontent and will oppose the liege
Opinion for I like this character 25 opinion
Opinion for I do not dislike this character and the character is unlanded opinion is BELOW -9 (???)

Revoke title[edit]

Pattern Vote Tooltip Notes
Dynasty player.png Selfish against I would lose a title!
Dynasty close relative.png Family against My family member would lose a title! Close relative and NOT a rival
Loyalist.png Loyalist for This voter is a Loyalist and will vote like the liege
Pragmatist.png Pragmatist for The targeted characters demesne is 4 or larger
Glory Hound.png Glory Hound against I do not want you to weaken Powerful vassals!
Zealot.png Zealot for Different religion and opinion below 20
Zealot.png Zealot against The target is pious and of my religion Same religion and piety at least 200
Malcontent.png Malcontent against This voter is Malcontent and will oppose the liege
Opinion for I dislike this character Opinion is -15 or below

Imprison, banish, or execute[edit]

Pattern Vote Tooltip Notes
Dynasty player.png Selfish against This affects me negatively
Dynasty player.png Selfish against This affects the stability of the Council! Fellow voter and NOT a rival
Dynasty close relative.png Family against My family member would be affected negatively Close relative and NOT a rival
Loyalist.png Loyalist for This voter is a Loyalist and will vote like the liege
Glory Hound.png Glory Hound against I do not want you to weaken your Dynasty!
Glory Hound.png Glory Hound against There is no glory in this, the character is a defenseless child!
Glory Hound.png Glory Hound against I do not want you to weaken Powerful vassals!
Zealot.png Zealot for Different religion and opinion below 20
Malcontent.png Malcontent against This voter is Malcontent and will oppose the liege
Opinion for I dislike this character Opinion is -5 or below for imprisonment
Opinion is -10 or below for banishment or execution

Strategies[edit]

  • It is often possible to avoid having to buy favors by finding new council members with the correct stance for the action you want to take.
  • Try to have at least half of your council be Loyalist  or cheap to buy favors from. Baron-level characters are the cheapest at 40g+. Courtiers require 80g, but you can often get their money back (inheritance if they have no family; banishment if they abuse their office).
  • Avoid letting your council members hold favors on you, unless you have (or will soon) have absolutism. They will often use their favors to start votes to increase council power.
    • If a council member gains a favor on you, you may wish to fire them from the council. You can also use the Buy Favor interaction to "buy back" the favor, but opinion must be high: "- I have better use for the favor"

Modding[edit]

  • Stance selection is defined in common/council_positions/
  • Voting patterns, for both laws and interactions, are defined in common/council_voting/
Realm
Landed titles
Concepts
De jureDemesneFeudalismTitular titleCouncilCouncil vote